Send Close Add comments: (status displays here)
Got it!  This site "creationpie.com" uses cookies. You consent to this by clicking on "Got it!" or by continuing to use this website.  Note: This appears on each machine/browser from which this site is accessed.
Greek: rough and smooth breathing
by RS  admin@creationpie.com : 1024 x 640


1. Greek: rough and smooth breathing
Ancient Greek has words that have either rough or smooth breathing diacritical marks at the beginning of the word. This mark is also used with the "r" character "rho" as "ρ".

This aspiration was used only for a short time in Attic (classical) Greek and had disappeared by the time of Koine Greek in the GNT (Greek New Testament). Nevertheless, these markings have been retained as part of the (cumbersome) historical notation for ancient Greek.

This disappearance leads to some interesting play on words for words that, according to aspiration, were not as close sounding as they were in practice.

2. Some notations
In some English notations for ancient Greek, the following are used.

3. Diacritical marks

4. Iota subscript
Word usage per chapter Words: ιωτα=1

 ᾳ = α +  ͅ = ᾳ = ᾳ
 ῃ = η +  ͅ = ῃ = ῃ
 ῳ = ω +  ͅ = ῳ = ῳ
αι ᾳ α
ηι ῃ η
ωι ῳ ω

At one time in ancient Greek, the letter "ι" as English "iota", when following the Greek letters "α" (alpha), "η" (eta), and "ω" (omega), had a distinguishable sound.

Eventually, the sound difference disappeared but the iota was still written. Once learned, academics (scribes) never give up the complexity.

Sometimes this iota subscript analogy is used by pastors but this iota subscript did not exist in GNT or LXX (Septuagint) times.

Information sign More: Matthew 5:18 The true reality of jots and tittles

5. Play on words

The ancient Greek word (smooth breathing) "ὄρος""mountain".
The ancient Greek word (rough breathing) "ὅρος""boundary, definition".

The smooth and rough breathing were close enough to be used as play on words but had disappeared by the time of Christ.

The ancient Greek words (and sounds) merged in modern Greek as "όρος" (O-ros) ≈ "mountain, definition, boundary".

Information sign More: Matthew Mustard seeds and moving mountains

6. Pure ignorance
Verse routePhilippians 4:8 whatsoever things are pure… [kjv]
Verse routeτο λοιπον αδελφοι οσα εστιν αληθη οσα σεμνα οσα δικαια οσα αγνα οσα προσφιλη οσα ευφημα ει τις αρετη και ει τις επαινος ταυτα λογιζεσθε [gnt]

Ivory Soap is 99.44% pure and it floats! That specific number appears to have resulted due to a rounding error in calculations that was then adopted as part of a marketing slogan.

[chaos theory]
In a sense, the Greek word for "pure" (rough breath) can be a play on words with "ignorant" (smooth breath). This may or may not be important here.


Information sign More: Ignorance of agnostic lack of belief
Information sign More: Germanic g to English y
Information sign More: Philippians 4:8 Logical calculation

7. Modern Greek
Greek letter
In ancient Greek, the "χ" or "chi" sound was more like a hard "kh" sound but not the "k" sound used by pastors or those who have learned the Middle Age pronunciation system invented by the Dutchman Erasmus (and pronounced differently in different parts of the world). This pronunciation system used by pastors is sometimes called "cowboy Greek".

In modern Greek, the "χ" or "chi" sound in the middle of a word is like a softened but still somewhat hard "kh" sound. However, the "χ" or "chi" at the beginning of a word is like an English "h" sound. If that aspiration were to disappear, that "χ" or "chi" at the beginning of a word would become silent.

8. Greek pronunciation
The Dutchman Erasmus (1466-1536) developed a way to pronounce Biblical (and Classical) Greek in the Middle Ages (about 1500 A.D.). This pronunciation is used by many traditional scholars of Biblical Greek such pastors (cowboy Greek, dead language). Thus, "thank you" as pronounced by pastor cowboy Greek is "you-carry-toe". This is the basis, through Latin, of the English word "eucharist" or "thank you".

Information sign More: Thank you for giving thanks and for Thanksgiving

9. End of page

by RS  admin@creationpie.com : 1024 x 640